2017-01Forum
Freedom, Symmetry Breaking and Reflective Judgements. An Attempt at an Incompatibilist Account of Freedom

Abstract:

In this paper free volitions are construed as a subclass of reflective judgements in the Kantian meaning, i.e. judgements not involving any fixed concepts but displaying a concept-like form. Judgements expressing volitions and issuing in action may be termed volitional judgements, therefore free volitions are construed as reflective volitional judgements. Due to an element of conceptual novelty and the fact that in a reflective judgement volition gets conceptually fixed out of an unstable equilibrium between different conceptualizations, free volitions thus construed seem to be apt candidates for causally undetermined events.

Keywords:

determinism, free will, freedom, incompatibilism, Kant, reflective judgement

How to cite:

Poręba, Marcin. “Freedom, Symmetry Breaking and Reflective Judgements. An Attempt at an Incompatibilist Account of Freedom.” Eidos. A Journal for Philosophy of Culture 1, no. 1 (2017): 67–75. https://doi.org/10.26319/EIDOS-001-FREEDOM.

Author:

Marcin Poręba
Institute of Philosophy, University of Warsaw
Krakowskie Przedmieście 3, 00-927 Warsaw, Poland
m.poreba@uw.edu.pl

References:

Dummett, Michael. “Tense and Time.” In Thought and Reality. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2006.

Dummett, Michael.  “The Reality of the Past.” In Truth and Other Enigmas. London: Duckworth, 1978.

Goodman, Nelson. Fact, Fiction, and Forecast. Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1983.

Kant, Immanuel. Critique of Practical Reason. Translated by Werner S. Pluhar. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, 2002.

Kant, Immanuel. Critique of Pure Reason. Translated by Paul Guyer and Allen W. Wood. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998.

Kant, Immanuel. Critique of the Power of Judgement. Translated by Paul Guyer and Eric Matthews. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000.

Kant, Immanuel. Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals. Translated by Allen W. Wood. Connecticut: Yale University Press 2002.

Łukasiewicz, Jan. „On Determinism.” In Selected Works, edited by L. Borkowski, 110–128, Amsterdam/London: North-Holland Publishing Company, 1970.

Łukasiewicz, Jan „On Three-Valued Logic.”, In Selected Works, edited by L. Borkowski, 85–86. Amsterdam/London: North-Holland Publishing Company, 1970.

Łukasiewicz, Jan „Philosophical Remarks on Many-Valued Systems of Propositional.” In Selected Works, edited by L. Borkowski, 53–178. Amsterdam/London: North-Holland Publishing Company, 1970.

Poręba, Marcin. Możliwość rozumu. Ćwiczenia z metafizyki (The Possibility of Reason. Exercises in Metaphysics). Warszawa: Aletheia, 2008.

Spinoza, Benedict de “Letter LVII.” In The Chief Works of Benedict de Spinoza. Translated by R.H.M. Elwes. London: George Bell and Sons, 1901.

Open Access Statement:

This is an open access journal which means that all content is freely available without charge to the user or his/her institution. Users are allowed to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to the full texts of the articles, or use them for any other lawful purpose, without asking prior permission from the publisher or the author, as long as the author and original source are properly cited. This is in accordance with the BOAI definition of open access.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. Submitting a text to Eidos. A Journal for Philosophy of Culture means that the author agrees with the general conditions of this license. The author does and will maintain copyrights and publishing rights for his/her article without any restrictions.

situs toto
toto togel
pam4d
situs toto resmi
toto togel
situs togel
togel online
pam4d
situs toto
situs togel
situs toto
situs toto
cerutu4d
situs toto
cerutu4d
situs togel
daftar gimbal4d
gimbal4d
situs toto
situs toto
toto slot
toto slot
toto slot
bandar togel
situs toto
situs toto
situs toto
rimbatoto
bo togel
bo togel
bo togel
situs toto
situs togel
bakautoto
situs toto
togel
situs togel
bakautoto
togel resmi
bakautoto
bento4d
bento4d
situs toto
jacktoto
situs toto
situs toto
toto slot
bo togel
situs toto
jacktoto
slot gacor hari ini
situs toto
slot gacor
togel online
bandar togel online
bo togel
bo togel
situs togel
rimbabola
situs togel
toto togel
togel online
situs togel
situs togel
togel online
situs togel online
cabe4d
slot gacor hari ini
situs toto
toto togel
situs toto
situs toto
situs toto
situs toto
jacktoto
situs toto
rimbabola
situs togel online
situs togel
situs toto
situs togel
jacktoto
situs toto
situs toto
situs toto
situs togel
situs toto
bakautoto
bo togel
bakautoto
situs toto
bo togel
situs toto
togel online
bandar togel
situs togel
situs togel
situs togel
situs togel4d
bakautoto
situs toto
situs toto
situs toto
situs bandar togel
situs togel
bandar togel resmi
situs toto
cerutu4d
togel online
situs toto togel
situs toto
situs toto
toto togel<
toto togel
situs toto
cabe4d
situs togel
bandar togel
situs toto
situs toto
PAM4D
PAM4D
PAM4D
gimbal4d
situs toto
cabe4d
bandar togel
bo togel
agen togel
situs toto
bandar toto macau
situs toto
situs toto
cabe4d
togel online
situs toto
agen deposit pulsa
pam4d
situs toto
bandar togel
situs togel
pam4d
situs togel
situs togel
situs toto
situs toto
situs toto
situs toto
situs togel
situs togel resmi
toto macau 4d
togel terpercaya
toto slot
toto slot
https://caselledental.com/
situs togel
situs togel
situs toto
jacktoto
slot gacor
cerutu4d
situs toto togel
situs toto
situs toto
cerutu4d
cerutu4d
bo togel
bo togel
toto togel
bandar togel terpecaya
cerutu 4d
bandar togel
situs togel
bandar togel
situs togel
cerutu 4d
situs toto
situs togel
situs togel
situs toto
situs togel
bandar togel terpecaya
situs togel terpercaya
cerutu 4d
toto togel
toto togel
bo toto
togel resmi
togel terpercaya
bo toto
link togel resmi
situs togel
togel online
bo togel
cabe4d
situs togel
situs togel
situs togel
togel online
jacktoto
jacktoto
bo togel
toto slot
bandar togel
bo toto
situs toto
situs toto
situs toto
toto login
situs toto
situs togel
bandar togel
bandar togel
situs toto
situs toto
togel online
situs toto
agen togel
bo togel
togel online
togel deposit dana
situs togel
situs toto
situs toto
jacktoto
bo toto togel
situs togel
bandar togel terpecaya
https://smkn2depoksleman.sch.id
slot gacor
situs toto
slot gacor
toto togel
situs toto
toto togel
situs togel
situs togel
10 situs togel terpercaya
situs togel
rimbatoto
rimbatoto
rimbatoto
rimbatoto
rimbatoto
rimbatoto
situs toto
bandar togel
situs toto togel
situs toto
bandar togel
situs togel
situs toto macau
bento4d
bo togel
situs togel
situs togel
https://stabilitas.id/
https://ipanel.id/
https://www.devilzdigital.co.id/
situs toto
situs toto
situs togel
bandar togel
situs togel
slot maxwin
situs toto
situs togel
slot toto
slot terpecaya
slot toto
slot Gacor
togel online
cerutu 4d
slot gacor
toto slot
bandar togel
bandar togel terbesar
monperatoto
monperatoto
situs toto
bento4d
bandar togel
situs toto
situs toto
situs togel
bandar togel
situs togel
situs togel
bento4d
situs toto
togel online
bento4d
situs togel
situs toto
situs togel
bento4d
situs toto
situs toto
bento4d
situs toto
situs togel
situs togel
situs togel
bento4d
situs toto
slot gacor
situs togel
situs toto
agen togel
bandar togel
bento4d
bento4d
bandar togel
bandar toto macau
bo togel
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
situs togel
bento4d
situs togel
situs togel
situs togel terpercaya
https://sydneynightpools.org/
togel
situs toto
agen togel
situs togel
bandar togel terpecaya
bo togel
situs toto
situs toto
slot gacor
situs toto
situs togel
pam4d
situs toto
bo togel
bandar togel
situs toto
situs toto
bento4d
situs togel
situs toto
situs toto
situs togel
situs togel
situs toto
cabe4d
situs toto
rimbatoto
rimba toto
bandar togel terpecaya
toto slot
situs togel
bandar togel
bandar togel
monperatoto
bandar togel
situs toto
link togel
situs toto
bandar togel
agen toto
bandar togel
situs togel resmi
situs toto
situs togel resmi
situs toto
jacktoto
situs toto
bo togel
situs toto
bo togel
situs toto
togel online
slot gacor
gimbal4d
bandar togel
bandar togel
bo togel
bandar togel
toto togel
bo togel
cerutu4d
cerutu 4d
rimbatoto
situs togel
situs togel
situs toto
bandar togel
situs toto
situs togel
bo togel
bandar toto macau
togel
situs toto
togel online
bo toto
slot gacor
situs toto
situs toto
slot gacor
bo togel
slot gacor
slot gacor
bo togel
situs togel
slot gacor
bo togel
bandar togel
bo togel
situs togel
bandar togel online
bandar togel
cerutu 4d
toto slot
bandar togel
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
situs toto
situs togel
pam4d
toto togel
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
slot gacor
situs togel
bandar togel
bo toto
situs toto
bandar togel
situs toto
bandar togel
bo togel
situs toto
bo togel
situs togel resmi
bandar togel
situs togel
situs toto
situs toto
situs togel
bandar togel
situs toto
bandar toto
situs togel
situs togel
bandar toto
situs toto
situs toto
bandar togel
situs toto
bo togel
situs togel
toto slot
situs togel online resmi
situs togel toto
situs togel resmi toto
situs togel
bakautoto
bakautoto
bakautoto
monperatoto
monperatoto
bento4d
bento4d
bento4d
bento4d
bento4d
bo togel
bandar togel
bandar togel
situs togel
bo togel
situs togel
situs togel
situs togel
bandar togel terpercaya
situs toto
situs toto
situs togel
situs toto 88
situs toto
bo togel
situs togel
situs toto
situs togel terpecaya
situs toto slot
rimbatoto
bento4d
situs toto
bandar togel
situs togel
bandar toto
bandar toto
situs toto
situs togel
situs togel 88
bandar togel
situs togel
situs togel 88
bandar togel
situs toto
situs toto
bandar toto macau
situs togel
situs togel
bo togel
situs toto
bo togel
https://pafibengkuluutarakab.org/
https://pafiboalemokab.org/
https://pafibulelengkab.org/
https://pafibungokab.org/
https://pafibuolkab.org/
https://pafikablubuklinggau.org/
https://pafikabpenukal.org/
https://pafikabsumsel.org/
https://pafikabtanahselatan.org/
https://pafikabtanjungjabungselatan.org/
https://pafikabupatenacehbarat.org/
https://pafikabupatenacehjaya.org/
https://pafikabupatenacehutara.org/
https://pafikabupatenkaro.org/
https://pafikotapalangka.org/
https://pafikotaserong.org/
https://pafimusirawaskab.org/
https://pafipahuwato.org/
https://pafipangkajenekepulauan.org/
https://pafipcbatanghari.org/
https://pafipccirebonkab.org/
https://pafipckotajabar.org/
https://pafipcpaser.org/
https://pafipcpulaudeli.org/
https://pafipcsarolangun.org/
https://pafipemkobangli.org/
https://pafipemkopulaupramuka.org/
https://pafipemkoserangkota.org/
https://pafipemkotkerinci.org/
https://pafipemkotpalopo.org/
https://pafipemkotpasuruan.org/
bandar togel
bandar toto macau
bo togel
situs togel
bandar toto macau
monperatoto
bo togel
bandar togel online
bo togel
bo toto
situs toto
bandar togel
bandar togel
situs togel resmi
bo togel
toto macau
situs togel
situs togel
toto slot
bandar toto macau
slot gacor
situs toto
bandar togel
situs toto
bo togel
situs toto
situs toto
rimbatoto
situs togel
bo togel
bo togel
pam4d
togel online
situs toto
situs toto
situs toto
slot gacor
situs toto
situs togel
rimbatoto
situs toto
situs togel
situs toto
situs togel online
situs togel resmi
situs togel
situs toto 88
togel online
situs toto macau
situs toto
bo togel
togel terpecaya
situs toto
bandar togel
bo togel
situs toto
situs toto
bo toto
bo toto
toto togel
situs toto
bento4d
bandar togel
agen togel
situs toto
situs toto
situs togel
situs togel
situs toto
situs toto
situs toto
bandar togel
toto slot
bo togel
agen togel
bandar togel
situs togel
monperatoto
situs toto
bandar togel
agen toto
situs togel
bo togel
situs toto
bandar togel
situs togel
situs toto
situs togel
bandar togel
toto togel
togel online
situs toto
situs togel
situs toto
situs togel
slot gacor
bo togel
bento4d
situs toto
https://pafipemkobandaaceh.org/
https://pafipemkonusantara.org/
https://pafipemkosorong.org/
https://pafipemkopekanbaru.org/
https://pafipemkomobagu.org/
https://pafipemkopadangpanjang.org/
https://pafipemkopayakumbuh.org/
https://pafipemkosawahlunto.org/
https://pafipemkolubuklinggau.org/
https://pafipemkopagaralam.org/
https://pafipemkosubulussalam.org/
https://pafipemkoprabumulih.org/
https://pafipemkogunungsitoli.org/
https://pafipemkopadangsidimpuan.org/
https://pafipemkopematangsiantar.org/
https://pafipemkotidorekepulauan.org/
https://pafipulaupini.org/
https://pafipulausamosir.org/
https://pafipulaupadang.org/
https://pafipulausalahnama.org/
situs togel
situs toto
bandar togel
bandar togel terpecaya
situs toto
situs togel terpecaya
bandar togel
situs toto
bandar togel
bandar togel
toto slot resmi
situs slothttps://disdukcapil.salatiga.go.id/ngacor/slot gacortotomacau4dsitus totositus totositus totoslot gacorsitus togelsitus totoagen totositus togelsitus totositus togel resmislot gacorslot gacorslot gacorbento4d